all-that-is-golden

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Tuesday, 15 February 2011

More Dawn Treader/Silver Chair ramblings

Posted on 16:10 by simmo
Heard about these at NarniaWeb.com:

Narnia Trilogy Boxset  I've been expecting this for a long time.  ;)  My sister already has the first 2, though, so instead we'll probably be getting:

Voyage of the Dawn Treader  Release date: April 8.  And there's extra scenes!  And gorgeous cover art. 

The Voyage of the Dawn Treader is simply one of the very best movies I've watched in a while.  Mainly because the whole thing is great, and there are no cringeworthy or boring scenes that make you want to fastforward (and that's even more than I can say for Lord of the Rings).  I've heard other reviewers say they don't like the dialogue, or that there wasn't much of it...personally, I prefer less dialogue to cluttery, pretentious dialogue; and I thought that the dialogue was just the right level for kids and grownups alike.  It didn't seem notably cheesy to me, either.  The sets were lovely and the casting/acting wonderful; the Dawn Treader itself was gorgeous and book accurate (love tall ships!).  All in all, I'd say The Voyage of the Dawn Treader really is a classic.  I'd recommend it to almost anyone.

Next I'm hoping that they'll do The Silver Chair.  I'm rather a purist when it comes to this story, but I won't mind a few changes if it's as intelligently scripted as Dawn Treader.  :)  I have a feeling The Silver Chair is a difficult book to adapt, though, for various reasons.


  •  Plot:  Jill and Eustace's journey vs. the lost prince's story.  Which one will get more focus?  Unfortunately, the hike through Narnia and Etttinsmoor may be deemed too boring to spend much time on.  Though I think that part is essential to character development.
  • Characters:  There won't be any Pevensie siblings.  How very much different than the Pevensies will Jill and Eustace be portrayed?  Will it be a big deal at all?  How major a character will Puddleglum be (certainly a major character in the book, but not quite as much as Jill)?  Will Rilian be given an expanded role?  (I hope not.)  Will there be any narration by Jill?  It might break the continuity with the other films; but how else could we "read" her thoughts?
  • Settings:  Like most Narnia readers, I have a pretty vivid picture of the marshes, Harfang, and the Lady-of-the-Green-Kirtle's house in my head.  And like many Narnia readers, this picture is strongly based on the original illustrations.  The previous Narnia films tended to be quite different from the books (I'm still sad that the avenue to the Magician's House was omitted from Dawn Treader).  The Silver Chair being a rather dark, "winter's eve" type of story, there isn't much room for inaccuarcy.  Still, I hope it sticks to the original illustrations...
  • Dialogue/Script:  The Silver Chair is much less action-packed than LWW, PC, or VDT.  Rather, it's mostly about faith and persistence.  Most of the plot twists revolve around things people say, not big battle scenes or invading enemies or claiming a throne.  It will be interesting to see how this translates to screen. 

    Thoughts? 


    post signature
    Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
    Posted in announcement, narnia | No comments
    Newer Post Older Post Home

    0 comments:

    Post a Comment

    Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

    Popular Posts

    • "another man's treasure"
      Today we helped set up a rummage sale at church!  And my feet still hurt, from running around carrying and pricing stuff.  ;)  But I'm g...
    • Ronald Howard as Sherlock Holmes
      Someone at our church lent us a collection of TV episodes starring Ronald Howard as Sherlock Holmes .  I had heard of this series before and...
    • (no title)
      Merry  C h r i s t m a s !!!
    • Currently practicing
      This piece: Learning, or trying to learn, pieces by Bach used to be something highly frustrating to me.  And, once I had done so, I dreaded ...
    • Currently practicing
      This piece: It's got to be ready for performance by the end of April, or thereabouts.  Right now I can play the first 3 pages (up to abo...
    • A portrait of Miss Smith
      Art & sewing are in 3rd place in the poll (so far), so I thought I'd post another pencil drawing.  By the way, what kind of movi...
    • The return of the school year
      It's been quite some time since I've written a sizeable post!  But school started yesterday, and I also have orchestra rehearsal onc...
    • The Gryphon
      Almost Alice:  August 1-7 www.shieldmaidenthoughts.wordpress.com  (To the best of my knowledge, this image is in the public domain ) Another...
    • Opinions wanted: happy endings vs. sad endings
      Pretty much what the title says...I'd like to hear what everyone thinks about this:  when you get close to the end of a really, really g...
    • It's sad...
      Today I finished re-reading Kidnapped .  :(  It really is an excellent book; the plot seemed even more interesting this time, and the charac...

    Categories

    • 'space--the final frontier'
    • #can't even
    • ♬ classical music Monday
    • 20000 Leagues
    • 30 day challenge
    • about me
    • Adam Young
    • alice in wonderland
    • announcement
    • april fools day
    • art
    • austen
    • bach
    • birthday
    • book commentary
    • book review
    • books
    • books on the brain
    • bronte
    • Canadian Rockies 2011
    • Caspar David Friedrich
    • Celtic Thunder
    • character analysis
    • Character Letters
    • chesterton
    • chopin
    • Christmas 2009
    • Christmas 2010
    • Christmas 2011
    • Christmas 2012
    • Christmas 2013
    • coffee
    • computer science
    • conrad
    • cooking
    • costume drama
    • costumes
    • Createspace
    • cryptozoology
    • debussy
    • dickens
    • domingo
    • e-readers
    • Easter 2012
    • Easter 2013
    • excerpts from books
    • facts I will know forever
    • Faulkner
    • FicSwap 2010
    • geekery
    • gimp tutorial
    • Glimpses of Goodness
    • green tea
    • guest post
    • health
    • hello
    • heroes
    • Heroines Costume Series
    • Historical Costume Inspiration Festival
    • homeschool
    • Hornblower
    • humor
    • hvorostovsky
    • I ♥ Thursday
    • Jane Eyre event
    • journal 1
    • jules verne
    • July 4 1776
    • Kindle Direct Publishing
    • Lent
    • life advice
    • life and times
    • life is sweet
    • link recs
    • Literary Heroine Blog Party
    • lord of the rings
    • LPW
    • math
    • mendelssohn
    • moby-dick quotes
    • movie review
    • mozart
    • music
    • music video
    • my writing
    • mystery solved
    • nail polish review
    • nanowrimo 2013
    • narnia
    • National Poetry Day
    • new year 2012
    • New Year 2013
    • New Year 2014
    • news article
    • nonsense words
    • on my mind
    • on writing
    • open letters
    • opera
    • opera review
    • opinions wanted
    • pacific northwest
    • paper dolls
    • patriotic
    • people
    • personal
    • photo challenge
    • photos
    • pi day
    • piano
    • picspam
    • poetry
    • politics matter
    • quotes
    • random
    • randomosities
    • reichenbach fall
    • Rhett and Link
    • Robinson Crusoe Read-Along
    • school
    • schumann
    • sewing
    • shaham
    • sherlock holmes
    • ships
    • short story
    • snippets of story
    • somewhat random
    • St Valentine's Day
    • steampunk
    • summer
    • summer 2013
    • summertime ramblings
    • Summertime's End
    • tagged
    • tchaikovsky
    • thanksgiving
    • the hobbit
    • the mind of an author
    • the sea
    • the virginian
    • tutorial
    • tv review
    • very random
    • video
    • violin
    • vita reale
    • Weekend Quote
    • writing

    Blog Archive

    • ►  2013 (57)
      • ►  December (7)
      • ►  November (7)
      • ►  October (4)
      • ►  September (2)
      • ►  August (15)
      • ►  July (6)
      • ►  May (2)
      • ►  April (2)
      • ►  March (2)
      • ►  February (4)
      • ►  January (6)
    • ►  2012 (170)
      • ►  December (10)
      • ►  November (8)
      • ►  October (10)
      • ►  September (13)
      • ►  August (19)
      • ►  July (24)
      • ►  June (9)
      • ►  May (15)
      • ►  April (6)
      • ►  March (17)
      • ►  February (17)
      • ►  January (22)
    • ▼  2011 (140)
      • ►  December (15)
      • ►  November (7)
      • ►  October (14)
      • ►  September (13)
      • ►  August (6)
      • ►  July (10)
      • ►  June (20)
      • ►  May (14)
      • ►  April (11)
      • ►  March (13)
      • ▼  February (9)
        • Taking a hiatus
        • Moby-Dick book review: Part II
        • Moby-Dick book review: Part I
        • "O frabjous day! Callooh! Callay! / He chortled ...
        • More Dawn Treader/Silver Chair ramblings
        • Tutorial: 21st Century Vintage (coloring)
        • Jules Verne
        • "Art...is liable to take the strangest forms"
        • Mendelssohn
      • ►  January (8)
    • ►  2010 (125)
      • ►  December (6)
      • ►  November (9)
      • ►  October (12)
      • ►  September (15)
      • ►  August (12)
      • ►  July (10)
      • ►  June (12)
      • ►  May (9)
      • ►  April (8)
      • ►  March (12)
      • ►  February (10)
      • ►  January (10)
    • ►  2009 (8)
      • ►  December (8)
    Powered by Blogger.

    About Me

    simmo
    View my complete profile